Tracy Street is a short street in Downtown Buffalo, running for two blocks between Delaware Avenue and Carolina Avenue, running parallel to West Tupper and Johnson Park. Tracy Street is unique to the downtown area, as it is mostly residential homes, most of which date from approximately the 1860s.
Houses on Tracy Street
The street is named for Albert Haller Tracy. Some places spelled his middle name as “Hallar”, but his gravestone uses Haller, so I will use that here. Tracy Street was opened in 1838. Mr. Tracy originally owned the land occupied by the street. At one point, Mr. Tracy tried to sell the land and the houses along the street to Mr. Lewis Allen for $500 (approximately $12,000 in today’s dollars). Mr. Allen turned down the offer, saying that it was not worth that much money. By the 1860s, the land along the north side of Tracy Street was part of Rumsey Park, owned by one of the richest men in Buffalo.
Albert Hallar Tracy was born in Norwich Connecticut in June 1793. His father was a physician and Albert originally intended to follow his footsteps and study medicine. However, after deciding medicine was not his passion, he went to Batavia to study law. In 1815 he was admitted to the bar in the Village of Buffalo. He practiced law in partnership with James Sheldon and later with Thomas C. Love.
Mr. Tracy was elected to the House of Representatives in 1819, when he was only 24 years old. He ran on the Whig ticket and represented nearly all of Western New York. He turned 25 during the time between election day and his inauguration. He served three terms in Congress and was friends with many statesmen of the time, including future President Martin Van Buren.
During his time in Congress, one of the major issues at hand was the admission of Missouri to the Union. Mr. Tracy argued on the house floor against allowing Missouri as a slave state. Mr. Tracy stated:
“We are called up on now to act with promptitude and decision upon this question; that posterity will hold us responsible if we consent to entail this evil upon it; an evil which can only be eradicated hereafter by civil commotion and perhaps bloodshed….slavery engenders pride and insolence in him who commands, and inflicts intellectual and moral degradation on him who serves, that it is abominable and unchristian. Then why should we not apply this restriction? Why should we hesitate to prohibit such an institution in a State whose geographical position alone ought to exclude it?”
Missouri was eventually accepted as a slave state (with Maine as a free state) in what became known as the Missouri Compromise.
Mr. Tracy was considered to have an unusually brilliant and logical mind, which contributed to his success. In 1829, Governor DeWitt Clinton appointed him a circuit court judge; however, Mr. Tracy declined the post. Shortly after, he was elected to the New York State Senate, where he served from 1830 to 1838. During his term as a Senator, he served in the State Court for the Correction of Errors, in which the Senate was included. Mr. Tracy wrote more than 150 legal opinions during his time in the State Senate.
Mr. Tracy was one of the nine original members of the Buffalo Harbor Organization, which organized in 1819. He was also a member of the first Board of Directors of the United States Bank, which incorporated in Buffalo in 1826. In 1846, he helped to incorporate the University at Buffalo. He also served as President of the Buffalo Water Works Company from 1855 to 1859.
Later in life, Mr. Tracy moved from the Whig to the National Republican party.
Mr. Tracy married Harriet F. Tracy. Albert and Harriet had two sons – Albert Haller Tracy, Jr. and Francis W. Tracy. The Tracy family lived at the northeast corner of Court and Franklin Streets. Mr. Tracy died on September 19, 1859 and he is buried in Forest Lawn Cemetery. Harriet died in March 1876. Albert Jr died in 1874.
Francis (Frank) married Mary Robinson in 1862 and they had a child named Harriet in 1867. Frank suffered from alcoholism and Mary divorced him in 1871, and was awarded custody of Harriet by the court. Frank then married Agnes Ethel in 1873. Agnes was a popular broadway actress of the time. Frank died in 1886 at the age of 47. Frank’s will was contested by Mary on behalf of Harriet, but Agnes was awarded all of Frank’s fortune.
Read about other streets by checking out the Street Index.
Sources:
- “Tracy Street Linked to Lawyer Who was a Congressman at 24″Courier Express June 26, 1938, sec 5 p 2
- Biographical Directory of the United States Congress – Albert H. Tracy (id: T000343)
- “In the Matter of Probate of the Last Will and Testament of Francis W. Tracy”. New York State Reporter. Surrogate Court, Erie County, Filed November 18, 1886.
- Proctor, L.B. The Bench and Bar of New York. Diossy and Company: New York, 1870.
Discovering Buffalo, One Street at a Time 
I grew up in Buffalo on Oakmont St. I so appreciate the historical information you have found. It is interesting and educational. I had never heard of Tracy Street. Thank you so much. I truly enjoy reading these.
UB was originally University of Buffalo, a private school. If became University at Buffalo when purchased by NY State.
[…] and included: John B. Skinner, Francis H. Root, Grover Cleveland, William H Greene, Albert H. Tracy, Thomas F. Rochester, Joseph Warren, Allan Potter, Henry Lapp. The first Principal of the […]
[…] After selling the Niagara Square house, Mrs. Burt built a house just a few doors down at 37 Court Street, at the corner of Pearl Street. That’s right, just like the Burts having multiple streets, they also had two mansions! The house cost $20,000 in 1861(about $633,000 in today’s dollars). Mrs. Burt’s gardens were noted for their beauty. Mrs. Burt lived at the home with her son David Jr., daughter Maria, Maria’s husband Edward Reed, and Maria’s three children. I wasn’t able to find any pictures of this house, but it was said to be a grand mansion. The Burt family’s neighbor at the corner of Court and Franklin Street was Albert Tracy. […]
My mother was born in 1919 and grew up on Tracy Street with her 4 siblings. Her parents already passed when I came along so I never got to see the house. Might’ve been #63. Was Hutchinson HS nearby?
Yep, Hutchinson High is right around the corner from Tracy Street just one block away. There’s only houses on the south side of the street, which is numbered with even numbers so it likely had an even number. The north side of the street was part of Rumsey Park (check out my post on the Rumseys for more info on that!). In 1926, School 76 was built on the north side of the street, so I’m guesing your mother went there too? Most of the houses along the street look very similar and Here’s a zillow listing for the house at 62 Tracy to get an idea of what the houses look like today- https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/62-Tracy-St-Buffalo-NY-14201/30200087_zpid/